Login 
 
 Pref   Your subscriptions   Home   Help 
users@ml.mod-xslt2.com
mod-xslt2 - Users Mailing List
   
 
List info
 
 
 
Subscribe
 
 
Unsubscribe
 
 
Archive
 
 
Post
 



Advanced search
2004 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12
2005 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12
2006 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12
2007 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12
2008 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12

  previous   Chronological   next       previous   Thread   next  

Re: [mod-xslt users] History? Carlo Contavalli
  • From: Carlo Contavalli <ccontavalli@xxxxxxxxxxx>
  • To: users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • Subject: Re: [mod-xslt users] History?
  • Date: Fri, 12 Nov 2004 16:21:34 +0100
  • References: <17B724DA3C6154B28F2B83D1@max.nt.nada.kth.se>


  • On Fri, Nov 12, 2004 at 03:38:29PM +0100, Peter Svanberg wrote:
    > Could someone please explain the history of this mod-xslt? We are
    > using the code from <http://sourceforge.net/projects/mod-xslt>,
    > namely mod_xslt 2.0.4. Is that what is called "the original
    > mod-xslt2"? The term "mod-xslt2" doesn't occur anywhere in that
    > material, what I can find!
    >
    > So, is this built on that code?
    >
    > (Yes, I've seen
    > <http://www.mod-xslt2.com/software/archive/2004101700/modxslt-2004101700/doc/misc/comparison.txt>
    > but I'm still puzzled.)
    Uhm... did you take a look at
    http://www.mod-xslt2.com/doc/manual.xml?sect=3
    ?

    Ok, that's not very detailed, but in short here is how it
    all worked:
    1 - needed something with the capabilities of mod-xslt :)
    2 - couldn't really find one
    3 - took Philipp Dunkel mod-xslt (version 1.??), formerly
    available at www.mod-xslt.com (at the time, it was
    down) and sourceforge.net/projets/mod-xslt
    4 - started adding the few functionalities needed, with
    the idea to provide back a patch to the author,
    even if the project seemed unmaintained.
    5 - ended up rewriting the _whole_ code.
    6 - I thought it was not nice to send back a patch like
    that upstream, so renamed the module in mod_yaslt,
    Yet Another xSLT module, and started working on the
    documentation.
    7 - Since the mod-xslt project seemed still unmaintained, I
    contacted the author (Philipp) asking if he minded if I
    worked on the project and ended up as a project developer,
    promising I would send him my new code (version 1.3.0) in
    a very short time with a brand new internet site.
    8 - life is sad, it took Marco and me about 9 months to get
    the site completed and to release the source code, while
    I had estimated something like 2 (yes, we worked on this
    on spare time, and in that period we hadn't much spare
    time). As part of this job, we renamed everything back
    from mod_yaslt to mod_xslt.
    9 - in the mean time, I sent no mail to Philipp letting him
    know how everything was going (my fault, sorry..), and
    he probably thought I had disappeared, and started working
    again on mod-xslt, releasing version 2 of the module.
    10 - when we were ready to release, we put everything on
    www.mod-xslt2.com, and wrote back to him. But probably
    it was now late...
    11 - I googled the internet one more time, and still found
    lots of nice/unmaintained/buggy/never released mod-xslt
    projects. So, I contacted each one of the project developers
    with the purpose to find some way to join the efforts
    working on one same project... many of them didn't
    answer, some of them did, but nothing good came out,
    while Josh Nutzman and Tom Murray kindly allowed me
    to take over their own project on sourceforge,
    http://www.sourceforge.net/projects/modxslt/.

    Now, I believe mod-xslt name is _very_ confusing.
    The site is: www.mod-xslt2.com, the sourceforge project
    modxslt, .so modules mod_xslt, mxslt_module, and on the
    internet you can find almost all of these names as
    independent mod-xslt projects (mod-xslt, mod-xslt2,
    modxslt, mod_xslt). It would have probably been smarter
    to leave the name mod_yaslt...

    > BTW, is that project ended?
    I have no idea :), think not, since Philipp released some
    code on january and the site came back to life with some pages...

    Hope to have satisfied your curiosity,
    Cheers,
    Carlo

    --
    GPG Fingerprint: 2383 7B14 4D08 53A4 2C1A CA29 9E98 5431 1A68 6975
    -------------
    This dungeon is owned and operated by Frobozz Magic Co., Ltd.

    • References:
      Powered by Sympa